Competitive Bidding Program Survey Results

The ITEM Coalition has launched a survey looking at access to medical devices and assistive technology for people with disabilities. The survey also seeks to find differences in services for respondents in the Competitive Bidding Program Phase 1 areas compared to respondents in non-Phase 1 areas.

Respondents

Thus far, the survey has had 87 respondents. The vast majority (80%) currently receives Medicare benefits and nearly a half (44%) receives both Medicare and Medicaid benefits. Nearly all of the respondents are younger than 65 (87%) and use medical devices or assistive technology every day or almost every day (87%). The most common devices used are wheelchairs, support surfaces, such as mattresses and overlays, and walkers. Many respondents use multiple devices and have been using devices for more than 10 years (58%). The vast majority have not heard about the Competitive Bidding Program (75%). Many have encountered problems in the past two years acquiring new equipment or repairing old equipment (72%).

Phase 1 Respondents

Of the 87 respondents to the survey, only six come from a Competitive Bidding Program Phase 1 area. These respondents mainly answered the same way as the overall respondent base, but do report a higher percentage of problems in the past two years acquiring new equipment or repairing old equipment (87%). Additionally, despite repeated attempts by CMS to informing users in the Phase 1 areas, four of the six Phase 1 area respondents had not heard of the Competitive Bidding Program.

Findings

The biggest area of concern the survey has shown thus far is the amount of problems respondents have had in the past two years acquiring new equipment or repairing old equipment. Many respondents have had multiple problems. The 49 respondents who have had a problem in the past two years combine to report a total of 99 problems. The most reported problem is delay in delivery of a product (20%) followed by difficulty in contacting provider for repairs/assistance and supplier not providing the needed device (both at 13%).

Phase 1 Stories

One of the problems most reported by Phase 1 respondents is the inability to obtain the needed equipment. Whether it is due to Medicaid restrictions or a lack of the supplier carrying the product, these individuals and their families are forced to rely on equipment that isn’t suitable for their needs.

“Medicare doesn’t pay for the model of chair that meets my activity level, helps me maintain my independence, and ensures my safety. Medicare only pays for the lower end model wheelchairs that do not have the same shock absorption, stability, drive control, and speed as the higher end models. As an active user that frequently drives my chair around town, the extra speed, control, and stability are needed to maintain an active and independent life and to be safe and comfortable in the community.”
– Jason from Kansas

“My daughter has Spina Bifida. She will continue to use assistive technology and medical devices the rest of her life. She uses both crutches and wheelchairs for mobility and leads a very active life. She uses proper cushioning to prevent pressure sores. She also plays wheelchair basketball and other Paralympics sports and needs specific equipment to be able to do this. Staying active is very important for her health and weight.”
– Robin from Texas, whose supplier does not provide the devices needed

“My son, age 52, has severe traumatic brain injury and is total care. We have to use a wheelchair and it is difficult getting the right one. I have one now that is supposed to be a lightweight wheelchair but it is still heavy for me to take out of the car. I am 73 years old and take full care of him.”
– Arlene from Florida

Non-Phase 1 Stories

“I had to purchase my scooter myself and my walker was paid only partially by Medicare. I use the walker for short distances but need the scooter for longer distances. Medicare does not consider the scooter necessary because I use the walker inside my home.”
– Jean from Pennsylvania

“Justin received his first power chair when he was two and a half years old. He is using his third augmentative communication device after receiving his first when he was three years old. He depends on assistive technology for increased independence and being included in our community. He is a straight-A ninth grader taking all regular education classes and would not be where he’s at today without assistive technology.”
– Kris from Minnesota

“My current frustration is that Medicare does not pay for devices to assist in the shower. I need something different than a movable bath bench. I need something more stable that I can transfer onto for a shower. The shower wheelchair I purchased was not covered by Medicare, I paid for it out of pocket. It is 4-6 inches too high for me to use independently.”
– Barbara from Illinois

“Only cheaply made equipment ends up being available when the bidding process is in effect. The junk that is offered does not match what we require to live like normal people. Some people cannot leave their house because the wheelchair they received cannot operate outside.”
– Anonymous from Pennsylvania

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s